4-in-1 Convertible or 5-in-1 Convertible Cribs? Compared by Specs
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between a 4-in-1 Convertible vs 5-in-1 Convertible crib depends on your space and long-term plans. Both models share the same classic Benton design, GREENGUARD Gold certification, and durable pine wood construction. They also offer four adjustable mattress heights for growing infants. The main difference lies in the final bed configuration and included accessories. One model adds a built-in changer, while the other supports a full bed with a footboard. You need to decide which setup fits your nursery better.
Key differences
| Aspect | Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib |
|---|---|---|
| Configuration | 4-in-1 Convertible | 5-in-1 Convertible |
| Full Bed Setup | Headboard only | Headboard and optional footboard |
| Included Storage | Full-size changer with drawers | Not listed |
| Product Weight | 83 lb | 42 lb |
| Color | Pebble Gray | White |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer if
- You need a built-in changing station to save floor space in a small nursery.
- You prefer a darker, neutral tone like Pebble Gray for your decor.
- You only plan to convert the crib to a daybed or a full bed with just a headboard.
Choose Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib if
- You want the option to convert the crib into a full bed with both a headboard and footboard.
- You prefer a crisp White finish for your nursery.
- You want a lighter frame that is easier to move during assembly or rearrangement.
Verdict: The 4-in-1 model is ideal if you prioritize space-saving storage and a changing table. The 5-in-1 model is better if you want the most versatile long-term bed configuration. Both offer the same safety standards and classic design.
4-in-1 vs 5-in-1 Crib Specs
Configuration
The Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer converts to a toddler bed, daybed, or full bed with a headboard only. The Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib adds an optional footboard for the full bed setup. Both require separate purchase of conversion kits. The 5-in-1 model offers a complete full bed frame with headboard and footboard, providing a more traditional look for older children. The 4-in-1 stops at the headboard, which some may prefer for a minimalist aesthetic. You should choose based on whether you need the footboard for your child's room style.
Storage
Storage needs differ significantly between these two models. The 4-in-1 version includes a full-size changing table attached to the crib, featuring spacious drawers and a shelf for nursery essentials. This integrated changer saves floor space and keeps supplies within reach. The 5-in-1 model does not include a changer or drawers. It is a standalone crib, requiring you to purchase a separate changing table or dresser if you need storage. If you want an all-in-one solution for diaper changes and storage, the 4-in-1 is the practical choice. Otherwise, the 5-in-1 offers flexibility for your nursery layout.
Material
Both cribs are built with durable pine wood and composites, offering long-lasting strength and everyday reliability. The material composition is identical, ensuring similar durability and finish quality. The 4-in-1 model is described as having classic lines and stylish details, while the 5-in-1 shares the same versatile design. You get the same sturdy construction regardless of the configuration choice. The finish options vary by style, but the core material remains pine wood composites for both. This consistency means you do not sacrifice build quality for additional features.
Weight
Weight is a key factor for assembly and stability. The 4-in-1 Crib & Changer weighs 83 pounds due to the added changer and storage components. The 5-in-1 Convertible Crib weighs 42 pounds, making it significantly lighter. This weight difference reflects the absence of the changer unit in the 5-in-1 model. Heavier cribs may feel more stable, but lighter ones are easier to move during cleaning or rearranging. The 5-in-1 is easier to handle for two adults during assembly. Consider your strength and mobility when deciding which weight profile suits your home.
Dimensions
Overall dimensions are nearly identical for both models. The 4-in-1 measures 56.7 x 29.7 x 41.7 inches. The 5-in-1 measures 56.73 x 29.72 x 41.68 inches. These slight variations are negligible for room planning. Both fit standard crib mattresses. The 4-in-1 includes the changer in its footprint, so the width may feel larger in practice. The 5-in-1 has a smaller footprint without the changer. You should measure your nursery space carefully. Both models offer four adjustable mattress height positions. The size difference is minimal, so room layout should not be the primary deciding factor.
Which Graco Benton Crib Fits Your Needs
Parents needing integrated changing and storage
The 4-in-1 model includes a full-size changer with spacious drawers and a shelf. This built-in storage keeps nursery essentials organized without taking up extra floor space. You get the convenience of an attached changing table alongside the crib, saving you from buying a separate unit. It is the practical choice for smaller nurseries.
Buyers wanting maximum bed configuration options
The 5-in-1 convertible crib supports a full bed setup with both a headboard and an optional footboard. This provides a more complete adult bed look compared to the headboard-only option on the 4-in-1 model. If you plan to use the crib as a full bed later, this configuration offers greater versatility for your child's room.
Shoppers prioritizing lighter product weight
The 5-in-1 crib weighs 42 pounds, which is significantly lighter than the 4-in-1 model at 83 pounds. This difference makes the 5-in-1 easier to move or rearrange within your nursery. If you value portability or plan to move the furniture frequently, the lighter weight of the standalone crib is a clear practical advantage.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer | nursery organization and space efficiency | Check price of Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer on Amazon |
| 2 | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | full bed conversion and low emissions | Check price of Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib on Amazon |
The products compared
Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer
Best for: nursery organization and space efficiency
- Configuration
- 4-in-1 Convertible (what this guide is about)
- Convertible Configurations
- 4-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 4
- Material
- Pine wood and composites
- Includes Storage
- Changer, drawers, shelf
- Overall Dimensions
- 56.7"L x 29.7"W x 41.7"H
View on Amazon: Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer Affiliate link
This Graco Benton crib offers a 4-in-1 convertible design with a built-in changing table and storage drawers. It features four mattress height positions and is GREENGUARD Gold certified for low emissions. The unit weighs 83 pounds and measures 56.7 by 29.7 by 41.7 inches. It suits families who want an all-in-one nursery solution that saves floor space while maintaining safety standards.
Pros
- Includes a full-size changer and storage drawers
- GREENGUARD Gold certified for cleaner indoor air
- Four adjustable mattress height positions
- Converts to toddler bed, daybed, or full bed
Cons
- Only four convertible configurations compared to five
- Conversion kits sold separately
- One-year limited warranty
Good fit if
- You need a changing station built into the crib
- You want low-emission materials for your nursery
- You prefer a classic, versatile design
Skip if
- You require a five-in-one convertible configuration
- You want conversion kits included in the price
- You prefer a longer warranty period
Verdict: Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib with Changer is a practical choice for parents who prioritize integrated storage and safety certifications over maximum convertible versatility.
Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib
Best for: full bed conversion and low emissions
- Configuration
- 5-in-1 Convertible (what this guide is about)
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Material
- Pine & wood composites
- Overall Dimensions
- 56.73 x 29.72 x 41.68 in
- Product Weight
- 42 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Greenguard Gold Certified
View on Amazon: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib Affiliate link
The Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib offers five configurations, including a full bed setup. It measures 56.73 inches wide and 41.68 inches high. The unit weighs 42 pounds and uses pine and wood composites. It holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. This crib suits families seeking a versatile, safety-tested nursery piece that grows with the child.
Pros
- Converts to a full bed with headboard and optional footboard
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for cleaner indoor air
- Baby Safety Alliance verified for safety standards
- Built with durable pine and wood composites
Cons
- Conversion kits are sold separately
- Heavier at 42 pounds than some competitors
- Warranty is limited to one year
Good fit if
- You want a full bed conversion option
- You prioritize low-emission materials for nursery air
- You need a sturdy pine construction
Skip if
- You want included conversion hardware
- You prefer a lighter frame for easy moving
- You need a longer warranty period
Verdict: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib fits parents who want a full bed option and verified low emissions. It delivers reliable safety standards and durable materials for long-term use.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Graco Benton 4-in-1 Crib & Changer | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib |
|---|---|---|
| Convertible Configurations | 4-in-1 | 5-in-1 |
| Mattress Height Positions | 4 | not stated |
| Material | Pine wood and composites | Pine & wood composites |
| Includes Storage | Changer, drawers, shelf | not stated |
| Overall Dimensions | 56.7"L x 29.7"W x 41.7"H | 56.73 x 29.72 x 41.68 in |
| Product Weight | 83 pounds | 42 lb |
| Features | Convertible, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Greenguard Gold Certified |
| Configuration | 4-in-1 Convertible | 5-in-1 Convertible |
| Color | Pebble Gray | White |
| Dimensions | 56.7 × 29.7 × 41.7 inches | 29.7 × 56.7 × 41.7 inches |
| Weight | 83 pounds | 42 pounds |
| Size | 56.7"L x 29.7"W x 41.7"H | 29.7"L x 56.7"W x 41.7"H |
| Model | 04586-64F | 04530-211 |
Frequently asked questions
Is the 5-in-1 crib actually worth the extra cost?
The 5-in-1 configuration offers more versatility for long-term use. It includes an optional footboard for the full bed setup, whereas the 4-in-1 model uses a headboard only. If you plan to keep the bed into adulthood, the extra piece adds value. The 4-in-1 is better if you prioritize integrated storage over bed frame flexibility.
Does the 4-in-1 model convert to a full-size bed?
Yes, the 4-in-1 model converts to a full bed. It uses a headboard conversion kit for this setup. The 5-in-1 model also converts to a full bed but includes an optional footboard for a more complete look. Both models support the same mattress sizes and height adjustments for growing children.
Which Graco Benton crib is lighter and easier to move?
The 5-in-1 Graco Benton crib is significantly lighter. It weighs 42 pounds, while the 4-in-1 model with the changer weighs 83 pounds. The added weight in the 4-in-1 comes from the integrated changing station and storage drawers. If you move furniture often, the lighter 5-in-1 option is more practical.
Are the dimensions the same for both crib models?
The overall dimensions are identical but listed differently due to orientation. Both measure 56.7 inches in length, 29.7 inches in width, and 41.7 inches in height. The 5-in-1 listing swaps length and width in its spec sheet, but the physical footprint remains the same. You will need the same amount of floor space for either model.
Can I use the 4-in-1 crib without the changer attachment?
Yes, you can use the 4-in-1 crib as a standard crib without the changer. The changer is an integrated feature that adds storage and a changing surface. If you do not need the extra storage or changing station, the 5-in-1 crib provides similar core functionality without the bulk of the attached furniture.
Do both cribs have the same safety certifications?
Yes, both models share the same safety standards. They both feature GREENGUARD Gold certification to ensure low chemical emissions. Both are constructed from durable pine wood and include four adjustable mattress heights. The safety features are consistent across the Benton line, regardless of whether you choose the 4-in-1 or 5-in-1 configuration.
Which color options are available for each model?
The 4-in-1 model is available in Pebble Gray. The 5-in-1 model is available in White. Color choices may vary by retailer and season. You should check the current inventory for specific color availability. The construction quality and conversion features remain the same regardless of the color you select.