Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib or Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Convertible Crib? Which Graco Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The graco benton 5 in 1 convertible crib vs tristan 5 in 1 convertible comparison highlights two versatile nursery options. Both models offer a 5-in-1 conversion path and GREENGUARD Gold certification for cleaner indoor air. They share the same core functionality, converting from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed, or full bed. The main difference lies in their construction and added features. The Benton is a lighter, classic white design. The Tristan is heavier and includes built-in storage drawers.
Key differences
| Aspect | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Pine & wood composites | Not listed |
| Storage | Not listed | Includes drawer |
| Weight | 42 lb | 70.8 lb |
| Overall Dimensions | 56.73"W x 29.72"D x 41.68"H | 55"W x 30"D x 40"H |
| Color | White | Driftwood |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib if
- You prefer a lighter crib that is easier to move.
- You want a classic white finish for your nursery.
- You do not need built-in storage drawers.
Choose Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer if
- You need extra storage space for baby items.
- You prefer a driftwood color tone.
- You want a sturdier, heavier frame.
Verdict: Choose the Benton if you prioritize a lighter weight and a traditional white aesthetic without storage needs. Select the Tristan if you value integrated drawers and a driftwood finish. Both models provide reliable conversion capabilities and safety certifications.
Benton vs Tristan: Key Specs
Storage
The Graco Tristan includes a built-in drawer, offering immediate storage for diapers, wipes, or small linens. The Graco Benton does not list any integrated storage in its specifications. If you need to keep nursery essentials within arm's reach without adding separate furniture, the Tristan provides a practical advantage. The Benton relies on external solutions, which may require additional space or coordination with other nursery units.
Weight
The Graco Benton weighs 42 pounds, while the Graco Tristan weighs 70.8 pounds. The significant weight difference suggests the Tristan uses more material or includes heavier components like the storage drawer. A lighter crib like the Benton may be easier to reposition during cleaning or room rearrangements. The Tristan's heavier build might offer more stability but requires more effort to move. Consider your strength and frequency of moving furniture when weighing this factor.
Dimensions
The Graco Benton measures 56.73 inches in width, 29.72 inches in depth, and 41.68 inches in height. The Graco Tristan measures 55 inches in width, 30 inches in depth, and 40 inches in height. The Benton is slightly wider and taller, while the Tristan is slightly deeper. These minor differences may affect how each crib fits into your specific nursery layout. Measure your space carefully to ensure either model clears doorways and fits comfortably against walls without obstructing movement.
Mattress Support
The Graco Tristan offers four adjustable mattress height positions, including a specific newborn setting. The Graco Benton does not specify the number of height positions in its provided data. More height options allow you to lower the mattress as your baby grows and becomes more mobile, enhancing safety. If the Benton has fewer positions, it may limit your ability to adjust the sleep surface optimally over time. Check the manual for exact positions if considering the Benton.
Certification
Both the Graco Benton and the Graco Tristan hold GREENGUARD Gold certification. This means both products are screened for volatile organic compounds to support cleaner indoor air. The Benton is also Baby Safety Alliance Verified, indicating independent testing at an accredited lab. The Tristan is JPMA Certified and tested to meet ASTM and CPSIA standards. Both meet high safety benchmarks, providing peace of mind regarding air quality and structural safety for your infant.
Which Graco Crib Fits Your Nursery
Parents needing diaper storage
The Graco Tristan includes a built-in drawer for immediate storage of diapers, wipes, or small linens. The Graco Benton does not list any integrated storage in its specifications. If you need to keep nursery essentials within arm's reach without cluttering the room, the Tristan’s drawer is a practical advantage.
Shoppers preferring lighter weight
The Graco Benton weighs 42 pounds, making it significantly lighter than the Graco Tristan, which weighs 70.8 pounds. If you plan to move the crib often or want easier assembly with less heavy lifting, the Benton’s lower weight is a clear benefit for handling and placement.
Buyers wanting classic style
The Graco Benton features classic lines and stylish details with a versatile design that matches any nursery. It comes in White, Pebble Gray, Driftwood, Grey, Black, and Hazelnut. If you prefer a traditional aesthetic over the Tristan’s driftwood finish, the Benton offers a timeless look for your child's room.
The products compared
Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib
Best for: Standard nurseries needing certified safety
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Material
- Pine & wood composites
- Overall Dimensions
- 56.73 x 29.72 x 41.68 in
- Product Weight
- 42 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Greenguard Gold Certified
- Color
- White
View on Amazon: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib Affiliate link
The Graco Benton is a 5-in-1 convertible crib made from pine and wood composites. It measures 56.73 inches wide by 29.72 inches deep. This model holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. It converts to a toddler bed, daybed, or full bed. Conversion kits are sold separately. It suits families who want a classic white design with verified safety standards.
Pros
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for cleaner indoor air
- Converts from crib to toddler bed, daybed, and full bed
- Baby Safety Alliance Verified for safety compliance
- Built with durable pine and wood composites
Cons
- Conversion kits are sold separately
- Mattress is sold separately
- No storage drawer included
Good fit if
- You want a classic white crib with a versatile design
- You prioritize low-emission materials for nursery air quality
- You need a standard-width crib for a typical nursery
Skip if
- You need built-in storage drawers
- You prefer a crib with a changing table attachment
- You want conversion hardware included in the box
Verdict: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib fits buyers who want a certified, safe crib without extra storage features. It works well for standard nurseries where you plan to buy conversion kits later.
Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
Best for: Parents seeking safety certifications and storage
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Material
- Pine, engineered wood, wood composites
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 55 x 30 x 40 in
- Product Weight
- 70.8 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified
View on Amazon: Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer Affiliate link
The Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Convertible Crib offers a driftwood finish and includes a built-in drawer for storage. It is GREENGUARD Gold Certified, screened for over 10,000 chemicals. The frame weighs 70.8 pounds and measures 55 by 30 by 40 inches. You get four mattress height options, including a newborn setting. This model suits families who want a trusted brand with safety certifications and integrated storage.
Pros
- Includes a built-in storage drawer
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low emissions
- Four adjustable mattress height positions
- JPMA certified for safety standards
Cons
- Conversion kits sold separately
- Toddler guardrails sold separately
- Mattress sold separately
Good fit if
- You want a crib with built-in storage
- You prioritize low chemical emissions
- You need a standard size that fits most rooms
Skip if
- You want all conversion hardware included
- You prefer a crib without a drawer
- You need a different color than the available options
Verdict: Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Convertible Crib is a solid choice for parents who value safety certifications and integrated storage in a standard-sized frame.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer |
|---|---|---|
| Convertible Configurations | 5-in-1 | 5-in-1 |
| Material | Pine & wood composites | Pine, engineered wood, wood composites |
| Includes Storage | not stated | Drawer |
| Overall Dimensions | 56.73 x 29.72 x 41.68 in | 55 x 30 x 40 in |
| Product Weight | 42 lb | 70.8 lb |
| Storage | not stated | Drawers |
| Features | Convertible, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified |
| Configuration | 5-in-1 Convertible | not stated |
| Color | White | Driftwood |
| Dimensions | 29.7 × 56.7 × 41.7 inches | 30 × 55 × 40 inches |
| Weight | 42 pounds | 70.8 pounds |
| Size | 29.7"L x 56.7"W x 41.7"H | 30"L x 55"W x 40"H |
| Model | 04530-211 | 04589-407 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Graco crib is better for small nurseries?
The Graco Benton is the better choice for tighter spaces. It measures 29.7 inches in length and 56.7 inches in width. The Graco Tristan is slightly narrower at 55 inches wide but longer at 30 inches. You should measure your floor space carefully before choosing, as both frames are substantial.
Does the Graco Tristan come with drawers?
Yes, the Graco Tristan includes built-in drawers for storage. This feature allows you to keep diapers and wipes within arm's reach. The Graco Benton does not list any integrated storage in its specifications. If you need immediate storage, the Tristan model provides this convenience directly in the frame.
How much do these Graco cribs weigh?
The Graco Benton weighs 42 pounds. The Graco Tristan is significantly heavier at 70.8 pounds. The extra weight in the Tristan likely comes from its integrated drawer system. You will need more effort to move the Tristan during assembly or rearranging your nursery compared to the lighter Benton.
Are both cribs GREENGUARD Gold certified?
Both models offer GREENGUARD Gold certification for cleaner indoor air. The Tristan explicitly lists this certification in its features. The Benton is described as certified and safe in its verdict. This means both products meet strict chemical emissions limits, which is important for your baby's health in a confined room.
What colors are available for these models?
The Graco Benton is available in White. The Graco Tristan is listed in Driftwood. You should check current inventory for other color options, as availability can change. These finishes allow you to match your existing nursery decor, whether you prefer a classic white look or a softer gray tone.
Can I convert these cribs into toddler beds?
Yes, both are 5-in-1 convertible cribs. This configuration typically includes a toddler bed conversion. You may need to purchase conversion kits separately for the full range of conversions. This design allows the furniture to grow with your child, extending its usefulness well beyond the infant stage.
Which model has a taller frame?
The Graco Benton has a taller frame at 41.7 inches in height. The Graco Tristan stands at 40 inches tall. The difference is 1.7 inches. This height difference is minor but may affect how high you lift your baby during diaper changes. Both heights are standard for full-size cribs.