Graco Story 5-in-1 Convertible Crib Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The Graco Story 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer offers a practical solution for nurseries that need integrated storage and certified air quality. It features a full-size drawer and GREENGUARD Gold certification. This combination helps keep the room tidy while ensuring low emissions. You might still look for graco story 5 in 1 convertible crib alternatives if you prefer a different size, a distinct color like espresso or olive, or a different configuration. Some buyers may want a 3-in-1 model or a frame with bookshelf storage instead. Others might prioritize a lighter weight or a specific wood finish. We selected these picks because their published specifications overlap with the original product. Each option shares key traits such as convertible frames, built-in drawers, or safety certifications. This list compares 6 similar picks based on their dimensions, materials, and included features. You can review the specs to find the best match for your nursery layout and your child’s needs.
Our top pick: Graco Story 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer.
How the Alternatives Compare
Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
The Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is slightly smaller than the Story model, measuring 29 inches deep versus 29.7 inches. It weighs 1.4 pounds more at 53.1 pounds. Like the Story, it includes a drawer and holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low emissions. The Benton uses a Pebble Gray finish, offering a cooler tone than the Story’s Driftwood. You get the same 5-in-1 convertible frame and integrated storage. If you need a compact footprint that still meets strict air quality standards, the Benton is a direct alternative. It gives up the Story’s specific color option but maintains the core functionality and safety certifications you expect from Graco.
Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib
The Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib is the heaviest option here at 66.2 pounds, significantly heavier than the Story’s 51.7 pounds. It features an Espresso finish, providing a darker, richer look compared to the Story’s Driftwood. Like the Story, it includes a drawer and GREENGUARD Gold certification. The Hadley is slightly narrower in width at 29.9 inches compared to the Story’s 55 inches width, though dimensions vary by orientation. It offers the same 5-in-1 conversion path. You might choose the Hadley if you prefer a darker aesthetic and do not mind the extra weight. It provides the same storage and air quality benefits but with a distinct visual style.
Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
The Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is the heaviest model in this group at 70.8 pounds. It shares the Driftwood color and GREENGUARD Gold certification with the Story. Like the Story, it includes a drawer and converts through five configurations. The Tristan is slightly taller at 40 inches compared to the Story’s 42.2 inches height, and equally wide at 55 inches. It offers a sturdier build due to the higher weight. If you prioritize certified air quality and integrated storage in a Driftwood finish, the Tristan is a robust alternative. It gives up none of the core features but provides a heavier, potentially more stable frame for your nursery.
Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Crib with Drawer
The Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Crib with Drawer differs significantly in configuration. It converts to only three configurations, unlike the Story’s five. It features an Olive color, offering a unique green tone. Like the Story, it includes a drawer and GREENGUARD Gold certification. The Olivia is taller at 46 inches, making it a more substantial presence in the room. It weighs 57.3 pounds, slightly more than the Story. You should pick the Olivia if you do not need the full bed conversion option. It provides the same air quality and storage benefits but with a different height profile and color. It is ideal for nurseries where the 3-in-1 path is sufficient.
Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib
The Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib is made by a different brand but offers similar features. It weighs 61.7 pounds, heavier than the Story. It includes a drawer and is designed for durability. The Storybrooke comes in Pebble Grey, a neutral option. Unlike the Story, the provided data does not list GREENGUARD Gold certification for this model. It offers the same 5-in-1 conversion path and integrated storage. You might choose this if you prefer a different brand aesthetic or the Pebble Grey color. It gives up the explicit air quality certification mentioned for the Story but maintains the core convertible and storage functionality for your nursery.
Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib
The Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib is the widest model at 59.5 inches, significantly wider than the Story’s 55 inches. It is also the heaviest at 74.8 pounds. It features a White with Driftwood color scheme, offering a two-tone look. Like the Story, it includes a drawer and converts through multiple configurations, though only four. It is shorter at 35.3 inches in height. This model is unique for its bookshelf integration potential. You should pick this if you want a wider footprint and integrated book storage. It gives up the 5-in-1 path for a 4-in-1 setup but offers distinct storage versatility beyond standard drawers.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Graco Story 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
Best for: Nurseries needing integrated storage and air quality certification
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 4
- Material
- Pine wood, composites
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 54.96 x 29.65 x 42.3 in
- Product Weight
- 51.7 lb
View on Amazon: Graco Story 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer Affiliate link
The Graco Story is a 5-in-1 convertible crib in Driftwood, measuring 55 by 30 by 42 inches and weighing 51.7 pounds. It includes a full-size storage drawer with two compartments and pre-installed tracks for easier assembly. The frame uses pine wood and composites with four mattress height positions. It holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low emissions and meets Baby Safety Alliance standards.
Pros
- 5-in-1 convertible design for long-term use
- Full-size under-crib drawer with two organizer compartments
- GREENGUARD Gold certified for cleaner indoor air
- Pre-installed drawer tracks simplify assembly
- Four adjustable mattress height positions
Cons
- Toddler guardrail sold separately
- Conversion kit for daybed or full bed sold separately
- Uses wood composites alongside pine
Good fit if
- You need integrated storage in a small nursery
- You want a GREENGUARD Gold certified crib
- You prefer pre-installed hardware for easier setup
Skip if
- You need the toddler guardrail included in the box
- You require a full conversion kit included
- You prefer solid wood construction without composites
Verdict: Graco Story 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is a practical option for parents who prioritize indoor air quality and built-in storage. It fits nurseries where space is tight and organization is a priority.
Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
Best for: nursery storage and low-emitting safety standards
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 4
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Product Weight
- 53.1 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified
- Dimensions
- 29.9 × 30.5 × 5.25 inches
View on Amazon: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer Affiliate link
The Graco Benton is a 5-in-1 convertible crib with a full-size storage drawer. It measures 29.9 inches long and 30.5 inches wide, weighing 53.1 pounds. The adjustable mattress support offers four height positions. It holds a GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. This model suits you if you want a classic, versatile design that adapts as your child grows.
Pros
- Includes a full-size under-crib storage drawer with two compartments
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for cleaner indoor air
- Four adjustable mattress height positions
- Converts from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed
Cons
- Heavier at 53.1 pounds than some lighter competitors
- Mattress is sold separately
- Drawer compartments are fixed and not adjustable
Good fit if
- You need extra storage in a small nursery
- You prioritize low-emitting materials for your baby's room
- You want a classic design that matches various decor styles
Skip if
- You prefer a lighter, easier-to-move frame
- You want a crib that includes a mattress in the box
- You need adjustable drawer compartments for different item sizes
Verdict: Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is a sturdy, certified option for parents who value air quality and built-in storage. It fits families who need a long-term solution that grows with their child without requiring extra furniture for organization.
Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib
Best for: storage and certified air quality
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 3
- Includes Storage
- drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 54.8 x 29.9 x 39.8 in
- Product Weight
- 66.2 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified
View on Amazon: Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib Affiliate link
The Graco Hadley is a 5-in-1 convertible crib in Espresso. It includes a full-size storage drawer with two compartments. The frame uses sustainable New Zealand pine wood. It features three mattress height positions for growing infants. This GREENGUARD Gold certified model fits standard crib mattresses. It converts to a toddler bed, daybed, or full-size bed. You get a practical nursery piece with built-in organization.
Pros
- Includes full-size storage drawer with two compartments
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low chemical emissions
- Converts to toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed
- Crafted from sustainable New Zealand pine wood
Cons
- Toddler guardrail and conversion kits sold separately
- Mattress is not included in the package
- Limited to one-year warranty coverage
Good fit if
- You need built-in storage for nursery essentials
- You want a GREENGUARD Gold certified finish
- You plan to convert the crib to a full-size bed
Skip if
- You want the toddler guardrail included
- You prefer a crib without a storage drawer
- You need a longer warranty period
Verdict: Graco Hadley Espresso 5-in-1 Crib offers solid construction and essential storage for parents who prioritize certified air quality and long-term versatility. It suits households ready to purchase separate conversion hardware and mattresses.
Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer
Best for: Nurseries needing built-in storage and low emissions
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Material
- Pine, engineered wood, wood composites
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 55 x 30 x 40 in
- Product Weight
- 70.8 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified
View on Amazon: Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer Affiliate link
The Graco Tristan is a 5-in-1 convertible crib with a built-in drawer. It weighs 70.8 pounds and measures 55 x 30 x 40 inches. The frame offers four mattress height positions, including a newborn setting. It holds a GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. This model suits families needing integrated storage and a trusted brand with safety certifications.
Pros
- Includes a built-in storage drawer
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low emissions
- 4 adjustable mattress height positions
- Converts to toddler, daybed, and full-size bed
Cons
- Heavier at 70.8 pounds
- Conversion kits sold separately
- Mattress sold separately
Good fit if
- You need built-in storage for baby items
- You prefer GREENGUARD Gold certified materials
- You want a convertible crib from a trusted brand
Skip if
- You want a lightweight crib under 60 pounds
- You prefer a crib without a storage drawer
- You need all conversion kits included
Verdict: Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer fits parents who prioritize certified air quality and integrated storage in a convertible frame. It is a solid choice for nurseries where space-saving drawers are essential.
Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Crib with Drawer
Best for: Nurseries needing certified air quality and drawer storage
- Convertible Configurations
- 3-in-1
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 53.75 x 29.75 x 46 in
- Product Weight
- 57.3 lb
- Features
- Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified
- Dimensions
- 29.8 × 53.8 × 46 inches
View on Amazon: Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Crib with Drawer Affiliate link
The Graco Olivia is a 3-in-1 convertible crib with an integrated storage drawer. It converts from a baby crib to a toddler bed and daybed. The unit measures 53.75 inches wide and weighs 57.3 pounds. It holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. This model suits you if you need a compact, certified crib with built-in organization for a nursery.
Pros
- GREENGUARD Gold certified for cleaner indoor air
- Includes a convenient under-crib storage drawer
- Converts from crib to toddler bed and daybed
- Verified by Baby Safety Alliance standards
Cons
- Only converts to three configurations, not five
- Toddler guardrail is not included
- Wider footprint than standard cribs
Good fit if
- You prioritize low-emission materials for your child's room
- You want built-in drawer storage without extra furniture
- You need a crib that converts to a daybed
Skip if
- You need a full 5-in-1 conversion to a full-size bed
- You expect the toddler guardrail to be included
- You prefer a narrower crib for small spaces
Verdict: Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Convertible Crib fits parents who value certified air quality and integrated storage over maximum conversion versatility. It is a solid choice for nurseries where organization and safety standards are top priorities.
Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib
Best for: Nurseries needing wood durability and storage
- Convertible Configurations
- 5-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 3
- Material
- New Zealand pinewood
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 54" L x 29" W x 43" H
- Product Weight
- 61.7 pounds
View on Amazon: Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib Affiliate link
The Dream On Me Storybrooke is a 5-in-1 convertible crib made from New Zealand pinewood. It includes an under-crib drawer for storage and offers three mattress height positions. The unit measures 54 inches long and weighs 61.7 pounds. It holds GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions. This crib suits buyers who want a classic design with practical storage that grows with their child.
Pros
- Includes a convenient under-crib storage drawer
- GREENGUARD Gold certified for low emissions
- Converts to toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed
- Made from solid New Zealand pinewood
Cons
- Conversion kits are sold separately
- Full-size mattress is not included
- Heavier build at 61.7 pounds
Good fit if
- You need extra nursery storage space
- You prefer solid wood construction
- You want a GREENGUARD Gold certified crib
Skip if
- You want all conversion kits included
- You need a lighter frame for easy moving
- You require a full-size mattress included
Verdict: Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib offers solid wood durability and essential storage for nurseries. It fits families prioritizing low-emission materials and classic styling over included accessories.
Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib
Best for: nursery storage and book organization
- Convertible Configurations
- 4-in-1
- Mattress Height Positions
- 4
- Material
- Pine wood and engineered wood
- Includes Storage
- Drawer
- Overall Dimensions
- 59.5 x 29.5 x 35.3 in
- Product Weight
- 74.8 lb
View on Amazon: Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib Affiliate link
This Graco Read-with-Me crib converts from a baby crib to bookshelves. It includes a storage drawer and weighs 74.8 pounds. The frame uses pine and engineered wood with four mattress height positions. It is GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low chemical emissions. This model suits you if you want a nursery piece that becomes functional storage for books after the toddler years.
Pros
- Converts to functional bookshelves
- Includes a storage drawer
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified
- Four mattress height positions
Cons
- Limited to 4-in-1 conversion
- Guardrail kit sold separately
- Mattress sold separately
Good fit if
- You want built-in book storage
- You prefer a 4-in-1 conversion path
- You value low-emission materials
Skip if
- You need a 5-in-1 conversion
- You want a toddler guardrail included
- You prefer a solid wood frame only
Verdict: Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib fits parents who want a nursery piece that transitions into practical bookshelves. It is a solid choice for those prioritizing low emissions and integrated storage over a full toddler bed conversion.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Graco Story 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer | Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer | Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer | Graco Olivia 3-in-1 Crib with Drawer | Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Crib | Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Convertible Configurations | 5-in-1 | 5-in-1 | 5-in-1 | 5-in-1 | 3-in-1 | 5-in-1 | 4-in-1 |
| Mattress Height Positions | 4 | 4 | 3 | not stated | not stated | 3 | 4 |
| Material | Pine wood, composites | not stated | not stated | Pine, engineered wood, wood composites | not stated | New Zealand pinewood | Pine wood and engineered wood |
| Includes Storage | Drawer | Drawer | drawer | Drawer | Drawer | Drawer | Drawer |
| Overall Dimensions | 54.96 x 29.65 x 42.3 in | not stated | 54.8 x 29.9 x 39.8 in | 55 x 30 x 40 in | 53.75 x 29.75 x 46 in | 54" L x 29" W x 43" H | 59.5 x 29.5 x 35.3 in |
| Product Weight | 51.7 lb | 53.1 lb | 66.2 lb | 70.8 lb | 57.3 lb | 61.7 pounds | 74.8 lb |
| Storage | Drawers | Drawers | Drawers | Drawers | Drawers | Drawers | Drawers |
| Features | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified | Convertible, Drawer, Greenguard Gold Certified |
| Configuration | 5-in-1 Convertible | 5-in-1 Convertible | 5-in-1 Convertible | not stated | Triple Bunk | 5-in-1 Convertible | 4-in-1 Convertible |
| Color | Driftwood | Pebble Gray | Espresso | Driftwood | Olive | Pebble Grey | White With Driftwood |
| Dimensions | 29.7 × 55 × 42.2 inches | 29.9 × 30.5 × 5.25 inches | 54.9 × 29.9 × 39.8 inches | 30 × 55 × 40 inches | 29.8 × 53.8 × 46 inches | 54 × 29 × 43 inches | 29.5 × 59.5 × 35.3 inches |
| Weight | 51.7 pounds | 53.1 pounds | 66.2 pounds | 70.8 pounds | 57.3 pounds | 61.7 pounds | 74.8 pounds |
| Size | 29.7"L x 55"W x 42.2"H | 29"L x 54.7"W x 41.7"H | 29.9"L x 54.8"W x 39.8"H | 30"L x 55"W x 40"H | 29.8"L x 53.8"W x 46"H | 54"L x 29"W x 43"H | 29.5"L x 59.5"W x 35.3"H |
| Model | 04583-057 | 04532-51F | 04521-709 | 04589-407 | 04522-70A | 6572-PG | 04688-771 |
For car seat setups, evaluate graco graco turn2me 3 in 1 convertible alternatives by their height and weight specifications.
Frequently asked questions
Are all these alternatives convertible cribs?
Most models listed are 5-in-1 convertible cribs. The Graco Olivia is a 3-in-1 triple bunk option. The Graco Read-with-Me is a 4-in-1 convertible crib. These configurations allow the furniture to change as your child grows. You can transition from a crib to a toddler bed or daybed.
Do these cribs include built-in storage drawers?
Yes, every model in this list features integrated storage drawers. This includes the Graco Story, Benton, Tristan, Olivia, and Read-with-Me. The Dream On Me Storybrooke also includes drawers. This design helps you keep nursery essentials organized without needing extra furniture in the room.
Which options have GREENGUARD Gold certification?
The Graco Benton, Hadley, Tristan, and Olivia models carry GREENGUARD Gold certification. The Graco Story is noted for air quality certification in its badge. The Dream On Me Storybrooke emphasizes low-emission materials. This certification indicates low chemical emissions for better indoor air quality.
How do the dimensions of these cribs compare?
Most models measure approximately 29 to 30 inches in depth. Widths range from 53.8 inches to 59.5 inches for the Graco Read-with-Me. Heights vary between 35.3 inches and 46 inches. The Graco Olivia is the tallest at 46 inches. The Graco Read-with-Me is the widest.
Is there a budget-friendly convertible crib option?
The Graco Tristan 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is labeled as the best budget pick. It offers a 5-in-1 conversion and includes a storage drawer. It also holds GREENGUARD Gold certification. This model provides essential features and air quality standards at a value-focused position in the lineup.
Can I find a crib with book storage?
The Graco Read-with-Me 4-in-1 Crib is designed for book organization. It transitions into practical bookshelves. This model is 59.5 inches wide, providing ample space for storage. It is ideal for parents who want to integrate reading materials directly into the nursery furniture.
Which crib is best for small nurseries?
The Graco Benton 5-in-1 Crib with Drawer is slightly smaller than the Story model. It measures 29 inches deep compared to 29.7 inches. It weighs 53.1 pounds. Its compact footprint and integrated drawer make it suitable for nurseries where space is tight and organization is a priority.
Does the Graco Olivia convert to a toddler bed?
The Graco Olivia is a 3-in-1 convertible crib. It is best for parents who value certified air quality and drawer storage. It offers less conversion versatility than the 5-in-1 models. It is a solid choice for nurseries where organization and safety standards are top priorities.